Tube Watch: Doctor Who – Cold War

by Cap'n Carrot on April 15, 2013 · 2 comments

in Television

After a bit of a miscalculation The Doctor (Matt Smith) and Clara (Jenna-Louise Coleman) materialize on a sinking Russian nuclear submarine near the North Pole in 1983 which has just picked up a rather unusual passenger in the form of a Martian Ice Warrior whose mere presence on the sub puts the entire crew, and perhaps even the entire world, in danger. While the ships first officer (Tobias Menzies) dismisses The Doctor’s explanation of events as pure rubbish, the ship’s Captain (Liam Cunningham) and scientist (David Warner) try to keep an open mind.

When one of the submarine’s crew attacks the Ice Warrior, thus declaring war for the entire planet, Skaldak (Nicholas Briggs) sends out a distress beacon calling other Ice Warriors to join him and lay waste to all who oppose him. The Doctor’s attempt to mediate the situation through the most nonthreatening person aboard the sub (namely Clara) doesn’t go quite as planned as the Ice Warrior leaves his armor chained up in the ship’s torpedo room to begin picking off the crew one-by-one.

As The Doctor hunts for the creature with the ship’s crew, Clara stays behind with the professor and begins to second guess her choice to travel with the mad man in a box. When his distress call goes unanswered Skaldak returns to his armor and decides to heat up the Cold War and begin the destruction of the entire planet Earth with a single missile after declaring the planet forfeit under Martian Law. Only the combination of Clara’s pleading and the eventual arrival of a Martian spacecraft halt Skaldak’s hand as the Martian Marshall leaves Earth more or less as he found it.

“Cold War” proves to be one of the creepiest episodes of the new series complete with a wonderful claustrophobic feel, the level of detail of the submarine set is terrific, and a only partially-seen monster reaching out from the darkness. In the show’s 50th anniversary season it’s good to see more classic returning creatures like the Ice Men whose original design is kept but updated for 2013. Clara’s doubts about traveling with The Doctor eventually subside, and in true companion tradition, she offers the right words at just the right time to help The Doctor save the day, and even sings a little Duran Duran to mark the occasion. After a couple of lukewarm episodes to start the second-half of Series Seven, it appears Doctor Who is back on track and moving ever closer to its 50th anniversary special in November.

  • Reddit
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Digg
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Posterous
  • Tumblr
  • CoosCoos

    I would respectfully disagree on the idea that the season is back on track. While I liked the Ice Warrior, the tension, and absolutely loved seeing David Warner, I still feel the episode fell flat. Once again it didn’t have any epic moments, and The Doctor didn’t really save the day so much as Skaldak showed mercy. Yes, The Doctor (and Clara) talked him into it, but it just didn’t feel persuasive to me.

    Plus, the CGI when Skaldak took off his helmet at the end didn’t seem up to par. Maybe it was the darkness of the sub, but it didn’t look very good to me. I hope they get their groove back soon.

    • Cap’n Carrot

      You’re certainly not alone as I’ve talked to others who didn’t like the episode’s final act, but for me it was very much classic Who with the companion providing the emotional argument or insight to help save the day.

      Although the CGI worked for me, I would have preferred not to have seen the Ice Warrior’s face at the end, especially with how well they teased not giving us a good look at him throughout the entire episode. Again, I liked the dark, claustrophobic feel of the episode with the villain always in the shadows about to pounce.

      And I liked seeing Clara go through the same kind of emotional arc Martha did in “42” where she finally realizes just what kind of danger she’s signed up for, but in the end decides the danger is worth the risk. (And could she be more adorable in that oversized Russian coat?)

Previous post:

Next post: